The Misconception - Just Eat Takeaway

Why is Takeaway.com so hated?

Why is the stock price down after its 4Q20 earnings print?

Why are people so shocked by the company’s decision to take down profit to capture market share – didn’t the company inform investors that they would do just such a thing, and history (Germany) would suggest that is the right strategy?

In this post, I would delve into what I believe is the company’s strategy and why the company is poised to win in the long run. This deserves a post itself, rather than a twitter thread (I usually only post when I feel like the market really misunderstand a critical fulcrum issue on a company - see previous posts on SE and NFLX).

Debate

What’s Takeaway strategy? Somehow, Fintwit has this conception that Takeaway is eBay or legacy GRUB – unwilling to change with the times and maniacally focused on profits.

Part of this is the fact that Jitse (Takeaway.com founder and CEO) kept saying that “logistics food delivery is not profitable in Continental Europe”.

However, believing that logistics food delivery is not fundamentally profitable and investing in logistics are not mutually exclusive.

Jitse has repeatedly said that logistics is necessary to keep consumers on the app, as consumers can get all the restaurants that they want on a single app and hence much less likely to churn.

This logic is pretty straightforward:

  1. It’s Friday Night and I would like to get a cheeky Nandos
  2. However, there is a pandemic so I can’t go out to Nandos
  3. So, I search Just Eat for Nandos
  4. There is no Nandos on Just Eat
  5. So I Google ”Nandos delivery” and found that Deliveroo would deliver Nandos
  6. I download the Deliveroo app and order Nandos

In order for Just Eat to keep that customer from going to another app, it has to offer logistics (Nandos). It is a customer retention tool.

However, because it has value as a customer retention tool does not mean it is very profitable, if at all.

In fact, without a delivery fee, that order would be very unprofitable. It is only after implementing a $3 delivery fee that the business works (barely).

Okay…but if logistics is so unprofitable/unappealing, why is JET trying to push Deliveroo and Uber Eats out with a $0 delivery fee strategy?

The answer is simple: to prevent logistics player from building a large enough customer base to enter the marketplace business.

While it is true that logistics is not profitable (much) as a standalone, it can be used as a customer acquisition strategy to build a large enough customer base such that it is possible for logistics players to acquire marketplace restaurants, which are very profitable. JET is trying to eliminate this risk.

Strategy

The strategy seems really simple to me:

    1.       Run logistics at $0 delivery fee, forcing Deliveroo and Uber Eats to match or lose market share
    2.       Deliveroo and Uber Eats won’t be able to match the delivery fee and so would lose market share
    3.       After winning the market, raise delivery fee (Germany and Netherlands) or instill minimum AOV (maybe $30) to make the unit economics work

JET can do this as the average logistics customers acquired also order from the highly profitable marketplace restaurants. Here is how it works:

    1.       I want to eat Nandos
    2.       Google Nandos and find that it is offered on JET for $0 delivery fee
    3.       Download the Just Eat app and order Nandos, but notice that other restaurants are available
    4.       Order from other restaurants in the future (which are likely to be marketplace restaurants)

JET will still be profitable if 75% of orders are from marketplace, and 25% from logistics (assuming no delivery fee)


However, Uber and Deliveroo would lose 550mn pound per year cumulatively (~750mn USD) if they try to match.

However, we must understand that Uber and Deliveroo are sub-scale relative to JET and so have inferior cost structure. Moreover, Uber has been giving a lot of promos to customers and those costs money. Using some reasonable assumptions, one might get to a total burn rate of ~GBP 860mn (nearly US$1.2bn) per year simply to match JET $0 delivery fee.

I do not think that sort of burn-rate is tenable especially as JET is able to operate at this unit economics indefinitely (as it is profitable). This is especially the case as we are simply talking about the UK. Imagine this situation occurring all across Europe (Spain, Italy, France) – the cumulative cash burn for the pair would be immense. Certainly, Deliveroo would not be able to finance this attrition war.

Moreover, JET has the extremely profitable Germany and Netherlands business which generates hundreds of million of EBITDA every year which can help in this “attrition war”, and a super valuable multi-billion $ stake in iFood which can (will) be monetized.

What if they match?

Someone might then say…well Uber has a lot of cash and a rideshare business which can be used to finance a food delivery war in the UK. Losing 2bn/year is no problem for Uber. The company has burnt MORE in the past!

That is true…but to what end? To defend a sub-scale market position where it has 20% market share (much of which were subsidized)? And a business that might break-even at best without a credible path to push out Just Eat?

And even if Uber decides to match, it is likely that it would still lose market share as it remains inferior on selection and coverage

So even if Uber and Deliveroo matches JET, they will still lose share because they are inferior in selection and coverage. What else can they do to defend their market position?

Here are some ideas (please reach out to me if you have any other ideas):

- Exclusivity contracts

  • Pro: prevent JET from getting those restaurants, and create differentiation
  • Con: very expensive – unit economics would be even worse.
  • What can JET do to counter: if anything, JET is in the better position to win exclusivity contracts as it has superior coverage (McD would prefer to be exclusive with JET as JET has the largest customer base and cover all of the UK – lots of benefits including efficient nationwide co-marketing)
- Bundled services
  • Pro: Uber can sell a subscription service bundling rideshare with food delivery and groceries à offer no delivery fee to customers with the pass, locking in users
  • Con: It does not actually make it cheaper because JET already has no delivery. Moreover, such a service likely covers a small % of the market as it is tailored to heavy rideshare users
  • What can JET do to counter: already offer $0 delivery fee. Work with other rideshare companies as well to create a subscription service (e.g. Lyft with GRUB)
- White-label delivery (allowing chains to offer delivery through their own app under their own brand)
  • Pro: align with the chains to offer a differentiated value prop (unique items or lower cost). The brand gets to tap an established logistics network and the logistics network get to capture demand
  • Con: this might just be the worst thing a food delivery company can do in the long-run, especially one that is dependent on chains. The platform becomes a commodity and capture a small fee for each order, and there is no benefit of customer acquisition. At some point, all the food delivery platform would do this and the chain restaurants (large % of logistics order) will simply funnel it out to the lowest cost vendor
  • What can JET do to counter: it would be ideal if competitors do not do this as it would be better for JET to capture a fee for offering the logistics in the future. However, if competitors do it, this basically ensures JET long term victory as it means competitors are giving up their inventory and has resigned to be a commodity (note that Deliveroo is already doing this with Nandos)

So, what does all of this mean?

This means that JET is very likely to win Europe and that the company will be incredibly profitable/valuable once it wins. It will instill a delivery fee (as in Netherlands and Germany) once it wins and likely minimum AOV to increase restaurant commission rate.

Please contact me in twitter if you think I am missing something.

Comments

  1. Great piece !! One remark: For Uber, the situation is slightly different: Uber Eats helps to a certain extent to increase work for their drivers and there might be some low CAC cross selling possible from their ride sharing customers. However this would only be a net positive if Uber Eats would turn somehow cash positive on a city level.

    JET is clearly trying to prevent it. I agree with you that Jitse's strategy makes a lot of sense. Uber made the mistake to allow ride sharing competitors to gain market shares in some markets which then allowed these competitors to attack them in other markets (pre Covid).



    ReplyDelete
  2. Very thoughtful analysis; Jitse's ability to adapt its strategy depending on the market situation is remarkable.
    @newmooncapital, would be great to connect

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i am following you but cannot write you directly. could you DM me? asteeox. speak soon!

      Delete
  3. Nice analysis, very insightful. Could you clarify what the difference is between Marketplace and Logistics?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Marketplace - Restaurants do their own delivery
      Logistics - 1P (platforms do the delivery)

      Delete
    2. Nice work! One difference in our assumptions relates to the final table you have showing the blended P&L assuming 75% marketplace. I would be surprised if, even once JET wins, it is able to earn higher unit / contribution margins on logistics vs. marketplace. The $3 delivery fee on logistics orders makes sense, but given the largest logistics restaurants are scaled QSR chains I'd be very surprised if the take rate is double the marketplace take rate. If anything it should be the other way around as the marketplace restaurants are mostly mom and pops. Do you disagree?

      Delete
  4. Nice work! One difference in our assumptions relates to the final table you have showing the blended P&L assuming 75% marketplace. I would be surprised if, even once JET wins, it is able to earn higher unit / contribution margins on logistics vs. marketplace. The $3 delivery fee on logistics orders makes sense, but given the largest logistics restaurants are scaled QSR chains I'd be very surprised if the take rate is double the marketplace take rate. If anything it should be the other way around as the marketplace restaurants are mostly mom and pops. Do you disagree?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nice analysis.
    One more idea how the logistics players could damage Jet:
    Wouldn't the Uber eats/Deliveroo be able to get after the marketplace restaurants and put them on their platform without much effort? If they do it becomes an issue for Jet as they have competition in the marketplace segment. The marketplace restaurants have definitive an incentive to be on multiple platforms as these could be a multiplier for their revenues.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey buddy, good to see you bud, and btw, you're really doing some nice things with the informational content on chatbot cost calculator. This is probably one of my favorite posts that you've written about healthcare software development company.

    But thanks so much for the kind words, I'm just trying to saying what's on my mind about OTT app development cost. If it works out, then great.

    ReplyDelete

  7. Nice post. I used to be checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Extremely useful info particularly the ultimate section 🙂 I take care of such information a lot. I was seeking this certain information for a long time. Thank you and best of luck.
    essay on cristiano ronaldo

    ReplyDelete
  8. Awesome Article thanks for share your valuable information and you are a restaurant owner build your business with features of our online food delivery software
    food delivery software

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks for sharing this nice palace for eating healthy and tasty food. Launch a Justeat clone app with the greatest online meal delivery software for your target client base, allowing people to order food from their favorite neighborhood eateries with a few simple taps. Thank You so much.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for sharing this blog here.very useful information for online food ordering system like Justeat clone script.

    ReplyDelete
  11. You can create a TRC20 or TRC721 Token through our Tron token development services and they will work seamlessly with their Ethereum counterparts.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Create your own DEX with like Uniswap our Uniswap clone script. Get decentralized exchange development from BlockchainX experts.Uniswap clone script

    ReplyDelete
  13. The migration platform works similarly to a DEX without the Automated Market Maker system. The New or V2 tokens are stored inside the migration smart contract and users can simply connect their web3 wallets to trustlessly migrate their tokens.Token Migration

    ReplyDelete
  14. Tron token development is your best choice if you want all the functionalities of Ethereum, without the outrageous gas fees. Our Tron token development services allow you to create and deploy tokens on the tron network in minutes

    ReplyDelete
  15. I know this is an amazing post, it defines the true value of your knowledge. In fact, running a business is not common. People keep running to drive more business and generate more customers. At LBM Blockchain Solutions which is best Blockchain development company in Mohali , you can maintain a leading position with Blockchain development in Mohali . keep it up. I really think this article is amazing, I can't describe it in words. Also, if you need best crypto exchange development company in Mohali
    , do not delay in shaking hands with LBM Blockchain Solutions.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Our Dapp development services help you create robust and scalable decentralized applications. As a Dapp development company with several years of experience, we provide you with industry-leading blockchain architects, smart contract developers, and web3 developers.
    DApp Development Solutions
    Build decentralized app

    ReplyDelete
  17. That was a very usefull information, thank you for such an awesome information, Checkout our Binance Website Clone
    Coinbase clone script

    ReplyDelete
  18. Thank you so much for sharing this informative post with us. Polygon Token Development Company

    ReplyDelete
  19. That was a very usefull information, thank you for such an awesome information, Checkout our Binance Clone Script

    ReplyDelete
  20. That was a very usefull information, thank you for such an awesome information, Checkout our Coinbase clone script

    ReplyDelete
  21. That was a very usefull information, thank you for such an awesome information, Checkout our paxful clone script

    ReplyDelete
  22. Launch your most prominent grocery delivery app with FreshDirect clone script app. We provide a white labelled grocery E-Commerce platform for retail businesses, markets in order to enhance the growth and reputation of the business.

    ReplyDelete
  23. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thank you for sharing this informative article. Explore our Copy Trading Software Development The Comprehensive Guide to Embarking on a Successful Trading Journey: Get Started Today!!!

    ReplyDelete
  25. "Your writings really demonstrate your depth of knowledge in the creation of cryptocurrency tokens! Your explanations' clarity and the depth of your knowledge never stop impressing me. Anybody interested in the crypto token development company can find a wealth of knowledge and inspiration from the books you've recommended. I was drawn to "Token Bridges" because it's a subject I've been wanting to learn more about. I appreciate you always providing such insightful content. You're a real expert in this area!"

    ReplyDelete
  26. Explore iMeta's cutting-edge, Axie Infinity Clone Script a groundbreaking software solution that mirrors the enchanting universe of Axie Infinity. Our white-label option, adaptable to your business logic, empowers you to dive into the thrilling realm of play-to-earn blockchain-based gaming. Revolutionize your venture and captivate players with a unique and customizable gaming experience.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment